MLB The Show 24 vs MLB The Show 25

Head-to-head comparison on Video Game Arena: MLB The Show 24 vs MLB The Show 25. See community win rates and vote to pick your winner.

MLB The Show 24

MLB The Show 24 cover art

Genre: Sports · Released: 2024 · Developer: SIE San Diego Studio · Platform: PC

Win Rate: 38% (5W / 8L · 13 battles)

View MLB The Show 24 full battle record →

MLB The Show 25

MLB The Show 25 cover art

Genre: Sports · Released: 2025 · Developer: San Diego Studio · Platform: PS5/Xbox/Switch/PC

Win Rate: 0% (0W / 4L · 4 battles)

View MLB The Show 25 full battle record →

Which is better — MLB The Show 24 or MLB The Show 25? Vote on Video Game Arena to make your pick count.

Global Leaderboard · Browse All Games