Best Simulation Games of All Time — Ranked by Players
The best simulation games of all time, ranked by head-to-head community votes on Video Game Arena. Every position is determined by real player votes — not critics or sales figures.
Top 10 Simulation Games (Player-Voted)
-
#1 —
Animal Crossing: Wild World
— Simulation · 2005 · Nintendo
· 100% win rate (10 battles)
-
#2 —
Animal Crossing: New Leaf
— Simulation · 2012 · Nintendo
· 93% win rate (15 battles)
-
#3 —
Animal Crossing: New Horizons
— Simulation · 2020 · Nintendo
· 88% win rate (8 battles)
-
#4 —
Stardew Valley
— Simulation · 2016 · ConcernedApe
· 86% win rate (29 battles)
-
#5 —
TCG Card Shop Simulator
— Simulation · 2024 · Mental Omega Interactive
· 79% win rate (14 battles)
-
#6 —
Goat Simulator
— Simulation · 2014 · Coffee Stain Studios
· 75% win rate (4 battles)
-
#7 —
Dave the Diver
— Simulation · 2023 · MINTROCKET
· 71% win rate (28 battles)
-
#8 —
Shadows of Doubt
— Simulation · 2023 · ColePowered Games
· 71% win rate (31 battles)
-
#9 —
Diddy Kong Racing
— Simulation · 1997 · Rare
· 68% win rate (19 battles)
-
#10 —
The Simpsons: Hit & Run
— Simulation · 2003 · Radical Entertainment
· 67% win rate (3 battles)
Vote now to help rank your favorite simulation games against the competition.
View the full leaderboard · Browse the game database
Frequently Asked Questions
How are these rankings determined?
Every ranking on Video Game Arena is determined purely by head-to-head community votes. Two games appear side-by-side and players pick the one they'd rather play — no critic scores, no sales figures. The more votes a game wins, the higher it climbs.
Can I vote to change these rankings?
Yes! Every vote you cast at Video Game Arena directly updates the leaderboard. Head to the arena, pick your favorites in head-to-head matchups, and watch the rankings shift in real time.
How often do the rankings update?
Continuously. Every vote from every visitor recalculates the rankings immediately. The list you see now reflects all votes cast up to this moment.